Top 5 DMARC and Email Authentication Tools of 2026
Red Sift OnDMARC, Valimail, dmarcian, EasyDMARC and Proofpoint Email Fraud Defense compared on enforcement, hosted SPF, BIMI, MTA-STS and published pricing.
Since February 2024, every major mailbox provider has required bulk senders to authenticate their mail. A domain sending more than 5,000 messages a day needs SPF (Sender Policy Framework), DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail) and a DMARC (Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting and Conformance) record. A DMARC record at p=none meets the rule but protects nothing. The tools below exist to get you from that monitoring record to enforcement without blocking your own invoices and password resets.
What the three bulk-sender rules actually require
| Provider | Effective | Threshold | DMARC minimum | Other requirements |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gmail | February 1, 2024 | More than 5,000 messages a day to personal Gmail accounts | p=none, with the From: domain aligned to SPF or DKIM |
One-click unsubscribe, spam rate below 0.30%, DKIM key of 1024 bits or longer |
| Yahoo | February 2024, rolled out through the first half of 2024 | Bulk senders | p=none, and DMARC must pass (relaxed alignment is fine) |
Both SPF and DKIM, one-click unsubscribe honored within 2 days, spam rate below 0.3% |
| Outlook.com | May 5, 2025 | More than 5,000 messages a day to hotmail.com, live.com and outlook.com | p=none, aligned with SPF or DKIM (Microsoft prefers both) |
SPF and DKIM must both pass |
Microsoft changed its plan on April 29, 2025. Instead of routing non-compliant mail to Junk, Outlook.com rejects it with the error 550; 5.7.515 Access denied, sending domain [SendingDomain] does not meet the required authentication level. Adding a sender to Safe Senders does not bypass the check.
None of the three providers requires p=reject. Gmail's own guidance stops at p=none. The reason to go further is spoofing: p=none tells receivers to deliver forged mail normally. It is also the gate for BIMI.
BIMI and MTA-STS in one paragraph each
BIMI (Brand Indicators for Message Identification) puts your logo next to your mail in supporting inboxes. Google's BIMI setup page requires DMARC at p=quarantine or p=reject with pct=100, a logo in SVG Tiny Portable/Secure format, and either a Verified Mark Certificate (VMC) or a Common Mark Certificate (CMC). A VMC needs a registered trademark, and only VMC senders get Gmail's checkmark. BIMI is the only mailbox-provider feature that rewards full DMARC enforcement.
MTA-STS (Mail Transfer Agent Strict Transport Security, RFC 8461) protects inbound mail rather than outbound. It tells sending servers to refuse delivery to your domain if they cannot set up a trusted TLS connection, which blocks downgrade attacks on STARTTLS. You publish a _mta-sts TXT record and a policy file at https://mta-sts.<domain>/.well-known/mta-sts.txt. Its companion, TLS-RPT (RFC 8460), sends you reports of failed TLS sessions. Hosting that policy file is the part most teams want a vendor to do.
For the rollout itself, see Roll Out DMARC to p=reject Without Breaking Mail and The Email Authentication Stack: SPF to BIMI. For BIMI costs, see What BIMI Actually Costs. For inbound phishing and business email compromise, which DMARC does not stop, see Top 5 Email Security Platforms of 2026.
Pricing and plan details below were checked on each vendor's own site in November 2026.
Quick Comparison
| Tool | Best For | Entry Price (Nov 2026) | Hosted SPF / DKIM | BIMI | MTA-STS Hosting |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Red Sift OnDMARC | Small to mid-sized domains that want every record type managed from day one | Express from $9/month billed annually (4 domains, 1M emails/month); higher tiers quote-only | Dynamic SPF, DKIM and DMARC on every tier (Express capped at 10 SPF lookups) | Dynamic BIMI on every tier; 1 VMC included on Enterprise and Premier | Yes, Dynamic MTA-STS and TLS-RPT on every tier |
| Valimail | Large sending estates and Microsoft 365 shops that want automated enforcement | Monitor free; Enforce (Starter, Premium, Enterprise) quote-only | Instant SPF (10 lookups free, unlimited paid); automated DKIM on Enforce | Listed on all tiers including free; Amplify add-on quote-only | Enforce only; TLS reporting on Monitor too |
| dmarcian | Teams that want published pricing, regional data residency and deployment help | Personal free (non-business); Basic $19.99/month billed annually; Plus $199; Enterprise $499 | SPF Surveyor analysis on all plans; no hosted SPF on the pricing page | BIMI Inspector and Builder on all plans | No hosted policy found; TLS reporting on all plans, self-host guides for the policy file |
| EasyDMARC | MSPs and agencies managing many client domains | DMARC Plus $35.99/month billed annually; Premium $71.99; higher tiers custom; 14-day trial | EasySPF from Premium; Managed DKIM from the Deliverability tier | Managed BIMI on every plan | Managed MTA-STS and TLS reporting from Premium |
| Proofpoint Email Fraud Defense | Existing Proofpoint customers who want consultants to run the project | Not published (demo request) | Hosted SPF, DKIM and DMARC records, no DNS lookup limits | Hosted BIMI | Not mentioned on the product page |
Red Sift OnDMARC
- Best For
- Small to mid-sized domains that want every record type managed from day one
- Entry Price (Nov 2026)
- Express from $9/month billed annually (4 domains, 1M emails/month); higher tiers quote-only
- Hosted SPF / DKIM
- Dynamic SPF, DKIM and DMARC on every tier (Express capped at 10 SPF lookups)
- BIMI
- Dynamic BIMI on every tier; 1 VMC included on Enterprise and Premier
- MTA-STS Hosting
- Yes, Dynamic MTA-STS and TLS-RPT on every tier
Valimail
- Best For
- Large sending estates and Microsoft 365 shops that want automated enforcement
- Entry Price (Nov 2026)
- Monitor free; Enforce (Starter, Premium, Enterprise) quote-only
- Hosted SPF / DKIM
- Instant SPF (10 lookups free, unlimited paid); automated DKIM on Enforce
- BIMI
- Listed on all tiers including free; Amplify add-on quote-only
- MTA-STS Hosting
- Enforce only; TLS reporting on Monitor too
dmarcian
- Best For
- Teams that want published pricing, regional data residency and deployment help
- Entry Price (Nov 2026)
- Personal free (non-business); Basic $19.99/month billed annually; Plus $199; Enterprise $499
- Hosted SPF / DKIM
- SPF Surveyor analysis on all plans; no hosted SPF on the pricing page
- BIMI
- BIMI Inspector and Builder on all plans
- MTA-STS Hosting
- No hosted policy found; TLS reporting on all plans, self-host guides for the policy file
EasyDMARC
- Best For
- MSPs and agencies managing many client domains
- Entry Price (Nov 2026)
- DMARC Plus $35.99/month billed annually; Premium $71.99; higher tiers custom; 14-day trial
- Hosted SPF / DKIM
- EasySPF from Premium; Managed DKIM from the Deliverability tier
- BIMI
- Managed BIMI on every plan
- MTA-STS Hosting
- Managed MTA-STS and TLS reporting from Premium
Proofpoint Email Fraud Defense
- Best For
- Existing Proofpoint customers who want consultants to run the project
- Entry Price (Nov 2026)
- Not published (demo request)
- Hosted SPF / DKIM
- Hosted SPF, DKIM and DMARC records, no DNS lookup limits
- BIMI
- Hosted BIMI
- MTA-STS Hosting
- Not mentioned on the product page
Red Sift OnDMARC
Best OverallBest for: Small to mid-sized domains that want SPF, DKIM, DMARC, BIMI and MTA-STS managed in one place at a published price
“Red Sift OnDMARC is the most complete DMARC tool you can buy without talking to sales. Its Express plan starts at $9 a month billed annually and includes Dynamic DMARC, SPF, DKIM, MTA-STS, TLS-RPT and BIMI, plus forensic reporting and API access. No other vendor on this list puts hosted MTA-STS and BIMI on its cheapest paid tier. The catch is the ceiling: Express covers 4 domains, 1 million emails a month and 30 days of history, and every tier above it is quote-only.”
Pros
- Express starts at $9 per month billed annually, per Red Sift's pricing page, the lowest published entry price in this comparison
- Dynamic Services manage DMARC, SPF, DKIM, MTA-STS, TLS-RPT and BIMI records from the OnDMARC console, so you change DNS once and then edit records in the product
- Express includes unlimited platform users, RESTful API access, role-based access control and SAML single sign-on
- Investigate checks a DNS change in seconds instead of waiting about 24 hours for the next aggregate report, per the pricing page
- Enterprise and Premier tiers include one Verified Mark Certificate, the certificate Gmail requires for its BIMI checkmark
Cons
- Express keeps only 30 days of report history and caps SPF at 10 lookups; unlimited Dynamic SPF starts at the quote-only Essentials tier
- Essentials, Enterprise and Premier prices are not published
- Radar, Red Sift's AI tool for finding and fixing issues, is limited on Essentials and needs Enterprise or Premier for Radar Pro seats
Why It Ranks First
The bulk-sender rules from Gmail, Yahoo and Outlook.com only require DMARC at p=none, so the value of a DMARC tool is how fast it gets you past that safely. OnDMARC's Dynamic Services move SPF, DKIM, DMARC, BIMI and MTA-STS records into one console on the entry tier. That removes the usual blocker in an enforcement project: waiting on a DNS team for every sender you add. Investigate then confirms each change without a 24-hour report cycle.
Where the Plans Split
Express is sized for a single brand: 4 domains, 1 million monthly emails and 30 days of history. Essentials raises that to 25 active sender domains, unlimited volume, unlimited parked domains, a year of history and unlimited Dynamic SPF. Enterprise adds 4 Radar Pro seats and one VMC, and Premier raises the domain count to 50 and adds DNS Guardian. Red Sift's FAQ says it bills in USD, EUR, GBP and AUD.
Express from $9/month billed annually; Essentials, Enterprise and Premier quote-only; free trial on every tier
Valimail
Best Free OptionBest for: Large or Microsoft 365-centered sending estates that want automated sender authorization and a free monitoring tier
“Valimail is the strongest choice when the hard part is the number of third-party senders, not the DNS syntax. Its paid Enforce product automates sender authorization and DKIM, and its free Monitor tier gives unlimited domain visibility with no card. Valimail calls itself the only DMARC platform preferred by Microsoft and lists an official Microsoft 365 partnership. Every paid tier is quote-only, and MTA-STS hosting is reserved for Enforce customers.”
Pros
- Monitor is free, offers unlimited domain visibility, and allows 5 users, per Valimail's pricing page
- Instant SPF allows 10 lookups on the free tier and unlimited lookups on paid tiers, which solves the SPF 10-lookup limit without manual flattening
- Enforce automates DKIM and sender authorization; Valimail says it reaches DMARC enforcement in 60 days or less
- MTA-STS hosting and TLS reporting are available, with TLS reporting open to Monitor users as well
- Valimail's homepage says more than 450,000 domains are secured by Valimail and DigiCert
Cons
- Enforce Starter, Premium and Enterprise are all quote-only, so you cannot budget from the website
- API access is an add-on on Starter and Premium; only Enterprise includes full API access
- MTA-STS hosting is Enforce-only and is not supported on Monitor
Automation Over Reports
Most DMARC tools parse aggregate reports and leave you to fix each sender. Valimail's Enforce product focuses on the fixing: it identifies senders from its library of more than 70 million pre-decoded IP addresses, per its homepage, and authorizes them in one click. For a company with dozens of SaaS platforms sending as its domain, that automation is the difference between a six-week project and a six-month one.
Free Tier and Its Limits
Monitor covers DMARC visibility and BIMI for up to 5 users at no cost. It does not include automated DKIM, subdomain views or executive reports, which start on Enforce Premium. That makes Monitor a good way to meet the Gmail, Yahoo and Outlook.com p=none requirement and read your reports. Getting to p=reject still means a paid Enforce contract or doing the sender fixes yourself.
Monitor free; Enforce (Starter, Premium, Enterprise) and Amplify (BIMI) quote-only
dmarcian
Best ValueBest for: Teams that want transparent per-plan pricing, regional data centers and hands-on deployment services
“dmarcian is the most transparent vendor here on price. Its pricing page lists every self-serve tier, from a free Personal plan to Enterprise at $499 a month billed annually, with domain, user and message limits for each. The company says it was founded in 2012 by a primary author of the DMARC specification, and it runs regional data centers in the Americas, APAC, Australia, Canada, the EU and Japan. It is weaker on hosting: we found no hosted SPF or MTA-STS policy service on its pricing page.”
Pros
- Every self-serve price is published: Basic $19.99/month, Plus $199/month and Enterprise $499/month billed annually
- Regional data centers in the Americas, APAC, Australia, Canada, the EU and Japan, per dmarcian's homepage, help with data-residency requirements
- BIMI Inspector and Builder, SPF Surveyor and TLS Reporting are included on all four plans, including the free one
- 30-day trial on paid plans with no credit card unless you continue
- Deployment, onboarding and consultation services are offered by dmarcian's own DMARC team
Cons
- Basic allows 2 domains, 1 user and 100,000 DMARC-capable messages a month, so most businesses outgrow it quickly
- The free Personal plan is for non-business use only and is reviewed for business domains
- Domain Discovery, API access and single sign-on are Enterprise-only
What Each Plan Buys
The tiers scale on three dimensions at once. Basic covers 2 domains, 1 user, 100,000 messages a month and 3 months of history. Plus covers 8 domains, 3 users, 1 million messages and a year of history, and adds IP safelisting and user access controls. Enterprise covers 15 domains, unlimited users, 5 million messages and unlimited history. Monthly billing costs more: $24, $240 and $600 for the same three plans.
Who It Suits
dmarcian fits a team that wants to read and act on its own reports with expert help on call. The deployment services and published per-domain pricing suit IT departments that must justify spend line by line. The company says more than 50,000 domain owners use it. Teams that want hosted records managed for them will find more of that in Red Sift or Valimail.
Personal free (non-business); Basic $19.99/month, Plus $199/month, Enterprise $499/month (billed annually); Custom quote-only
EasyDMARC
Best for MSPsBest for: MSPs, agencies and resellers managing DMARC across many client domains
“EasyDMARC is built around the managed service provider. It sells a dedicated MSP Email Trust Platform alongside its business plans, and says it has 90,000 customers in more than 130 countries. Business plans start at $35.99 a month billed annually for DMARC Plus, with Managed BIMI included. Hosted SPF (EasySPF) and Managed MTA-STS start on Premium at $71.99, and Managed DKIM needs a custom-priced tier.”
Pros
- Published business prices: DMARC Plus $35.99/month and DMARC Premium $71.99/month billed annually, with annual billing saving 20%
- Unlimited users on every plan, per the pricing page
- Managed DMARC and Managed BIMI are included from the entry plan
- Premium adds EasySPF hosted SPF, Managed MTA-STS, TLS reporting, AI agents and proactive DMARC alerts
- A separate MSP Email Trust Platform and DMARC for MSPs program cover multi-client management
Cons
- No free plan, only a 14-day trial with no credit card required
- DMARC Plus covers 2 domains and 3 months of history; Premium covers 4 domains
- Managed DKIM is only on the custom-priced Deliverability and Enterprise: Email Trust tiers
Built for Many Tenants
The MSP angle shows in the product lineup. EasyDMARC sells an MSP Email Trust Platform, a DMARC for MSPs offering, and programs for value-added resellers and wholesale partners. For an IT provider whose clients all received Gmail and Outlook.com bounce notices at once, a multi-tenant console with per-client reporting matters more than any single feature.
What Premium Adds
Premium is the plan most single businesses should compare against Red Sift Express. It adds EasySPF, Managed MTA-STS with TLS reporting, AI agents, proactive alerts and email support to the Plus feature set. At $71.99 a month billed annually it costs more than Red Sift Express but allows unlimited users and keeps a year of history instead of 30 days.
DMARC Plus $44.99/month or $35.99/month billed annually; Premium $89.99/month or $71.99/month billed annually; Deliverability and Enterprise custom
Proofpoint Email Fraud Defense
Best for EnterpriseBest for: Large enterprises, especially existing Proofpoint customers, that want consultants to run the DMARC project
“Proofpoint Email Fraud Defense (EFD) is a managed DMARC program more than a self-serve tool. Proofpoint's consultants identify senders, validate authentication and move you to a reject policy. Hosted Authentication Services then manage your SPF, DKIM and DMARC records without DNS lookup limits. EFD also adds lookalike domain detection across more than 650 million domains and supplier risk scoring. Pricing is not published, and the product page does not mention MTA-STS.”
Pros
- Proofpoint's consultants guide each phase of the DMARC rollout, per Proofpoint's product page
- Hosted SPF, DKIM and DMARC records remove the SPF 10-lookup limit and manual DNS edits
- Lookalike domain detection monitors more than 650 million domains for impersonation of your brand
- Supplier Risk Scoring rates the authentication posture of the third parties that email you
- Hosted BIMI keeps your logo record in step with DMARC enforcement
Cons
- No published pricing; the only path is a demo request
- MTA-STS is not mentioned on the product page
- Best value depends on already running Proofpoint's email gateway; as a standalone DMARC purchase it is the heaviest option here
Beyond Your Own Domain
DMARC only protects domains you own. EFD's other two features reach past that. Lookalike detection watches more than 650 million domains for registrations that imitate yours, and Supplier Risk Scoring flags vendors whose own weak authentication makes them an easy route for invoice fraud. Those are the gaps an attacker uses once your domain is at p=reject.
Fit With Proofpoint's Gateway
Proofpoint also ranks second on our email security platforms comparison, where its gateway, DLP and threat intelligence are the draw. Buying EFD from the same vendor keeps outbound authentication and inbound filtering under one contract. If you do not already run Proofpoint, that advantage disappears and the lack of published pricing becomes harder to justify.
Not published; demo request only
Which One Should You Pick?
| Use Case | Our Recommendation |
|---|---|
| Single-brand company that needs to meet the Gmail, Yahoo and Outlook.com rules and reach p=reject cheaply | Red Sift OnDMARC Express. From $9 a month billed annually it manages DMARC, SPF, DKIM, BIMI and MTA-STS for up to 4 domains, which covers the full rollout without a sales call. |
| Enterprise with dozens of SaaS platforms sending as its domain, mostly on Microsoft 365 | Valimail Enforce. Its automated sender authorization and DKIM handle the long tail of third-party senders, and its Microsoft 365 partnership fits a Microsoft-centered estate. Start on the free Monitor tier to size the problem. |
| IT team that must show line-item pricing or keep report data in the EU, Canada, Australia or Japan | dmarcian. Every self-serve plan is priced on its site, and it runs regional data centers in the Americas, APAC, Australia, Canada, the EU and Japan. |
| Managed service provider rolling out DMARC for many client domains | EasyDMARC. Its MSP Email Trust Platform is built for multi-client management, and its business plans include unlimited users and Managed BIMI from the entry tier. |
| Existing Proofpoint customer worried about supplier invoice fraud and lookalike domains | Proofpoint Email Fraud Defense. Consultants run the enforcement project, and lookalike detection plus supplier risk scoring cover the threats DMARC alone cannot. |
How we evaluated
This comparison ranks tools that help a domain owner publish SPF, DKIM and DMARC, read the reports, and reach p=quarantine or p=reject without blocking legitimate mail. Inbound email filtering is a separate category, covered on our email security platforms comparison.
Each tool was assessed on the criteria in the comparison table above:
- Path to enforcement: how the tool helps you find and authorize every sender before you turn on
p=reject, and how much of that it automates. - Hosted records: whether SPF, DKIM, DMARC and BIMI records can be managed in the product, and whether it solves the SPF limit of 10 DNS lookups.
- BIMI and MTA-STS: whether the vendor hosts the BIMI record and the MTA-STS policy file, and on which plan.
- Published pricing: whether the price is on the website, and how domains, message volume and history scale between tiers.
- Fit: the buyer each tool is actually built for, from a single brand to an MSP with hundreds of client domains.
What we reviewed
We reviewed each vendor's own pricing page, product pages and documentation in November 2026, plus the sender requirements published by Google, Yahoo and Microsoft. We did not run the products against a live sending estate. Vendor performance claims, such as time to enforcement, are attributed to the vendor.
PowerDMARC was considered. Its website blocked automated access when this page was written, so its pricing and features could not be checked on its own site. It is left out until they can be.
Editorial independence: this is a vendor-neutral comparison with no paid placements, sponsorships, or affiliate links. Rankings reflect fit for the stated use cases, not commercial relationships.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do Gmail, Yahoo and Outlook.com require DMARC p=reject?
What happens to mail that fails the Outlook.com requirements?
Which DMARC tools host MTA-STS for you?
What do I need for BIMI and the Gmail checkmark?
Is there a free DMARC tool?
Does DMARC stop phishing emails sent to my employees?
Related Comparisons
AI SOC Analyst / Alert Triage
Top 5 AI SOC Analysts of 2026: Dropzone AI vs Prophet Security vs Security Copilot Agents vs Torq vs Google SecOps
5 tools compared
Security Data Pipeline
Top 5 Security Data Pipeline Platforms of 2026: Cribl Stream vs DataBahn vs Tenzir vs Edge Delta vs Observo AI
5 tools compared
Security Control Validation
Top 5 Breach and Attack Simulation Tools for 2026: Cymulate vs SafeBreach vs Picus vs AttackIQ vs Pentera
5 tools compared
Secure Design and Threat Modeling
Top 5 Threat Modeling Tools for 2026: IriusRisk vs SD Elements vs ThreatModeler vs Threat Dragon vs Microsoft TMT
5 tools compared